dfotw, irreparable, and kitrinlu for contributing your time and your talents! I have picked my favorites from each of your submissions (apparently I was really looking for a magnifying glass theme and didn't even know it), and I'm going to let the community vote on which should be our new default icon. A poll will appear below the three choices. Unfortunately, anonymous users cannot participate in LJ polls, so if you want to vote, please consider making an account. I will close the voting after around 24 hr (so around 0730 PST, April 2, 2016).
Choice A: Icon #4 by DFOTW
Choice B: Icon #1 by Irreparable
Choice C: Icon #4 by Kitrinlu
Please vote for your favorite candidate.
A: Icon #4 by DFOTW
74(46.0%)
B: Icon #1 by Irreparable
21(13.0%)
C: Icon #4 by Kitrinlu
66(41.0%)
Edit: And that's that! Congratulations,
dfotw! 